It sounds like they want to timestamp bookmarked episodes. Which is a great idea actually. That way you can find the spot or spots that may be why you starred it.
It sounds similar to this request from 2016. I have often wanted to either add notes to a podcast episode, or mark a particular place for reference later. Several things come to mind
where to store this metadata
do we need to export it for the user eventually
what happens when the episode is not favorite and gets deleted?
Yes. That’s what I want.
That Feature is in the Samsung Voice Recorder. Verry nice Feature. And I think it’s not too hard to implement. One row in the ui and bookmarks on a card after the chapters.
Interesting how different people are using their apps. I’d never even consider using a favorite/star feature (and would be happy if that functionality could be hidden) let alone highlighting specific parts of podcasts.
But then again, I don’t reread books either which a lot of readers like to do.
Do you guys actually go back and listen again for fun or is it for research or something?
Maybe a sort of notes function. You hit a button, at the point you want the note, which puts a timestamp after which you can add a few words describing it. It could also favorite the episode. Ideally the timestamp would be clickable and take you to that point. Obviously that would not be a big deal.
If more podcasts were really good about show notes, this function would be useless.
Edit: I’ve thought about hand written notes, but then the data needed are in two spots. It’s just less efficient.
Also example of the timestamp would be YouTube. Like how you can link to an exact spot.
Cheers. I appreciate the clarification @Dragunbayne.
In short, yes, I do listen again. Sometimes I just find specific episodes to be very enjoyable and fun. Other episodes talk in such depth or complexity that I feel I need to listen again to fully understand what is being discussed. Yes, I have actually used it for research in the past as well.
I completely appreciate that point. But I also like the contrast between the two. The contrast between the tangible item I can hold in my hand and do not need electricity or anything else for it to work and this modern device I can hold in my hand that is thousands of times more powerful than the original computer that took an entire room.
Brilliant example! I hadn’t thought about that. We use that for work frequently and it’s enormously effective and saves time. Cheers!
I listen again for these reasons also. I like the time stamping idea for long podcasts where I may want to replay a point or story for myself or someone else.
Yes I really like this idea, for taking notes at a specific timestamp in a podcast. But I would also be really happy if there was even just a more simple implementation of note-taking in the app, a way to add a note for a whole episode. This way someone could summarize the podcast in their own words, or just simply write what was important for them. I’m sure there are other uses that people would make of this too.
For the implementation of the simple note taking feature, or the more complicated one, these are my thoughts:
A lot of people I believe would really like and use this feature, and could use it a lot, so I think that the button for it should be right next to the stream and download buttons.
Because of this prominence of the feature, for people who don’t like it, they could disable it, or maybe put it in an in between: accessing it through the three dots.
Then for people to see their notes, there’d be a tab for them in the app for it. They could see their notes in chronological order, or by podcast. They would be able to search them.
The thing about show notes is though that, they are sometimes longish, maybe talking about all of the ideas in the episode. They are really useful definitely for the listener, but even with good show notes, I believe that a notes feature is still needed, because the listener can write just what they think is important, what resonated with them. Also someone summarizing in their own words, having a short personal note, would be faster for people to look back at, more convenient.