Side navigation

I have searched for existing threads about this feature request

on

App version

3.13.0-beta1

Problem you may be having, or feature you want

Please :folded_hands: Don’t remove side navigation entirely.

I understand that maintaining two navigation styles creates extra work, especially for a small volunteer team. But for those of us who prefer the side navigation, losing that option is a significant downgrade.

Suggested solution

Could you at least consider keeping it as an alternative, or create a community poll to see how many users actually prefer side navigation over bottom navigation before removing it permanently?

As another side navigation user who has been using AntennaPod for over a decade, I’m baffled by the bottom navigation UX. I understand that lack of volunteer time means that AntennaPod devs cannot support old features forever.

Is there somewhere where I can read about the thinking behind this and how users are expected to move their usage? For example, a thing I often do is hit the hamburger menu or swipe in from the left side to quickly see a list of podcasts to check if any podcasts have a high unread count while also having a view of the latest episodes in the episodes page. This allows me to prioritize recency while also quickly pulling in a subscription-level context from the left that can be easily dismissed. I don’t see an easy way to do this with the new navigation.

I am aware that my workflow may look like the famous xkcd below, so apologies in advance :sweat_smile:

Even with side navigation, you can’t look at both at the same time because the side bar covers them, and to switch you need one click. By adding subscriptions screen and episodes screen to the bottom navigation, you get the same single-click switching you already had (plus it’s closer to the thumb). You can even change the subscriptions screen to a list if you prefer that over a grid.

(post deleted by author)

I understand the reasoning behind moving to bottom navigation, but personally, I find it more cluttered. I prefer having all the available sections together in one side menu that I can open when needed, rather than having several navigation buttons permanently taking up space, with the remaining sections tucked away in a separate menu.

I also find the side navigation visually cleaner and more modern. The bottom navigation, with its permanent row of buttons and separate overflow menu, feels more dated to me. The side drawer feels like a cleaner, more unified way of organizing the app.

Also, if I’m understanding Quadrifoliate’s point correctly, they’re using the side navigation for something a little different:

1. They’re on the Episodes page, sorted by latest publication date.

2. They swipe from the left to partially open the side navigation.

3. This lets them see their subscriptions and their unread episode counts while still keeping part of the Episodes page visible.

4. They can compare the information at a glance, then close the drawer without actually leaving the Episodes page.

5. I would have attached a video to demonstrate this, but the forum only allows image uploads. So I attached a screenshot showing the side drawer partially open over the Episodes page. In the video, I’m slowly swiping it back and forth to demonstrate how you can reveal the subscriptions and their unread counts while keeping the Episodes page visible, then close it again without navigating away.

If that’s what you mean, I can see why the side navigation is useful here. It’s not just about switching between sections; it’s about being able to temporarily see information from both without navigating away from either.

Is that what you meant, or have I misunderstood your point?

I understand that maintaining both navigation styles takes additional work, but I’d still like to see the existing side navigation retained as an alternative, without requiring the team to develop new features or improvements for it.

Like a “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.” Situation?

I don’t know if it helps but you can choose which button are at the bottom. For instance you could have subscriptions and episodes so you can switch quickly between both.

Subscriptions screen can also be set to a list instead of thumbnails, you can also change what counters indicate and how subscriptions are sorted. (Using counters being an option)

That’s the point, you can’t see both at the same time anyway. Then you can also just switch screens. The screens remember their scroll position, so you can quickly go back and forth between them.

This is not a “just keep it” situation, it is a “stop spending quite a large percentage of development time on keeping it working” situation. Unfortunately, this time required to “just keep it” has become too large. Google updates Android, we update libraries, we develop other features, and side navigation regularly gets in the way.

Though I don’t like side navigation, I understand those who love it. So, both ways deserve live together in this lovely app called Antennapod…:blush:

Nope, you got it exactly right, this is my workflow. It layers one piece of information over the other—it’s just like how you might have one terminal in front of another but not hiding it; and you can quickly click on either one to foreground that information. And continuing that analogy, the bottom navigation is like replacing it with two full-screen terminals, which you can never see at the same time.

As you can see in the screenshot, you can see bits of both at the same time. It’s a more “comforting” (for wont of a better word) affordance. See my analogy for terminals as well above.

Also, I don’t think this is quite right if you take into account swiping from the side, which is zero clicks. Other apps (like Spotify, Gmail, and ChatGPT on Android, to cite three common examples) also have this swipe-to-side-navigation UX, so I’m a little confused why it’s going away in AntennaPod.

An equivalent UX with bottom navigation would be something like swiping up from Episodes to reveal a horizontally scrolling list of subscriptions, etc; but in standard phone format the bottom has far less fewer pixels than the side; and swiping from the side is quite easy on large phones—which is probably why side navigation seems more common on apps. To quote the other user:

__________________________

Ultimately I don’t have much of a say here apart from being a really long-term user; but I’d like to just understand better what the thinking is behind bottom navigation; and why the side navigation is such a pain to maintain if other prominent apps also seem to have it.

Not to argue for bottom navigation, but IMHO, a lot of apps have switched to bottom navigation: YouTube, YouTube Music, Spotify, Deezer. I believe it’s because of gesture navigation making the use of a sidebar less convenient.

Actually, looking into this myself, as I shouldn’t expect the devs to spoon-feed me the references to existing discussions. I’d tried this only briefly earlier, and gave up too quickly.

Here’s what I can find:

One thing does puzzle me though—Material Design v3 says that the navigation bar (aka “Bottom Navigation”) should be used when there are 3-5 destinations. On the other hand, a navigation drawer (current “side navigation”) seems to be recommended for 5 or more destinations, which AntennaPod does have. We have Home, Queue, Episodes, Subscriptions, Inbox, Downloads, Playback history, Favorites, Statistics—all of which leads to the “More” screen and also a selection.

Just based on this alone, shouldn’t the app be going with purely a navigation drawer (side navigation) rather than shoehorning our large number of destinations into a navigation bar (bottom navigation) that has a “More” section?

Thanks for explaining. I hadn’t realized that simply keeping the side navigation working was taking up such a significant amount of development time.

I’m curious, though: is the main difficulty that the two navigation styles have separate implementations that need to be maintained, or that changes elsewhere in the app frequently cause issues with the side navigation? I’d appreciate a few examples to better understand what makes maintaining it so costly, even without adding new features or improvements.

I also want to make it clear that I’m not claiming to understand everything that goes on behind the scenes or how much work is involved in maintaining either navigation style.

But if maintaining both is the problem and the choice ultimately has to be between one or the other, why does the bottom navigation have to be the one that stays? Why couldn’t the side navigation remain while the bottom navigation is removed instead? From a user’s perspective, both are simply different ways of navigating the same app, and I don’t see why one should automatically take priority over the other.

I understand that the decision ultimately comes down to what is practical for the development team, but I wanted to raise that alternative.

Wouldn’t it make more sense to let the community have a say in that decision through a poll? That way, if only one navigation style can realistically be maintained, users could choose which one they’d prefer to keep rather than having that decision made for everyone.

Mostly that it is two styles at the same time. Recent examples are the navigation stack (“back” navigation) with predictive back gestures, and system bar insets breaking to show stuff behind the navigation buttons (for phones that still have those instead of gesture navigation).

As @Matth78 already wrote, apps are switching away from side navigation because it conflicts with gesture navigation. Actually, the main movement there was 5 years ago and AntennaPod is just late to the party.


Sorry, we are set on this. Give it 1-2 weeks and you still get uses to it. If you then still absolutely rely on side navigation, turn off automatic updates. The app does not depend on a central server, so it will likely continue working for a long time.

I understand that maintaining two navigation styles creates additional technical work, and I’m not claiming to understand everything that goes on behind the scenes. The examples you gave make the maintenance difficulties clearer.

That said, I’m not entirely convinced by the argument that other apps have been moving away from side navigation. Apps like YouTube and Spotify have had bottom navigation for years, so this isn’t exactly a new development. But that doesn’t necessarily mean side navigation has become obsolete or that bottom navigation is automatically the better choice for every app.

For example, Podcast Addict (if I’m remembering correctly) still uses a side navigation menu to access its various sections. This shows that the approach is still relevant, even within the same category of apps as AntennaPod.

Ultimately, I think AntennaPod should be judged by its own needs and the way people use it, rather than simply following what other popular apps have chosen. I still believe a community poll would have been a reasonable way to determine which navigation style users would prefer to keep if maintaining both is no longer practical.

I just wanted to explain why I think retaining side navigation would have been a better fit for AntennaPod and its users.

I understand now that the decision has been made and that it doesn’t seem likely to change at this point. So rather than continuing to argue over which navigation style should stay, I’d like to suggest a few improvements that could make the new layout feel more polished and less cluttered.

When I’m listening to an episode and the mini-player is visible, having it stacked directly above the bottom navigation makes the lower part of the interface feel quite bulky. The two elements look like separate layers placed on top of each other rather than parts of a cohesive layout. I’d like to see them integrated more naturally so the interface feels less cluttered.

I also noticed that the bottom navigation remains visible even when opening an episode in the full player. This wasn’t something I was used to with the old side navigation, and I found it particularly inconvenient when navigating through muscle memory. I often use the app while working with my hands or without looking directly at my phone, so I rely on knowing where the controls are. With the new navigation in a different position, I kept tapping the wrong things without realizing it until I looked at the screen. I’d much prefer if the bottom navigation could be hidden on screens like the full player and individual podcast pages, rather than remaining visible everywhere.

One other thing I’ve noticed is the spacing between subscriptions on the dedicated Subscriptions page. I know this page has always been available, with both column and list layouts, but I personally prefer the more compact appearance of the subscription list in the old side navigation. Since the available space there was narrower, the subscriptions were displayed closer together, which I found much cleaner. If possible, I’d like to see the list layout on the dedicated page offer similar spacing or give us more customization options.

I realize these are ultimately design decisions, but since it seems we’re going to be moving forward with bottom navigation, I think addressing these points would go a long way toward making the new interface feel more seamless and less cluttered.

Thanks for taking the time to explain everything and consider my feedback. I appreciate it.

I am fine with the bottom navigation. At least for me it takes a click out of my workflow. Also the “Now Playing” is on all of the buttons.

One thing I would like to see is effectively not having to open the Now Playing panel to get to the shuttle controls: Skip Back, Skip Forward, Skip Next Podcast. I could see this in a couple of ways, with by making the mini-panel (the current one) taller with the controls or have the full Now Playing panel come up. That said, these are not showstoppers for me. I know the shuttle controls are available on the lock screen widget.

Keep up the great work.