Actually, looking into this myself, as I shouldn’t expect the devs to spoon-feed me the references to existing discussions. I’d tried this only briefly earlier, and gave up too quickly.
Here’s what I can find:
- Here’s the issue for bottom navigation, filed in August 2020: Bottom navigation · Issue #4376 · AntennaPod/AntennaPod · GitHub
- The reason was as follows: “With the new interface standards on iOS and Android, bottom navigation bars are becoming common. It would be a good idea to place the common functions - Subscriptions, Episodes, Downloads, Playback History and Queue in the bottom navigation bar for faster access and less swipes/taps.”
- Here’s the corresponding brainstorming thread: Brainstorming bottom navigation (for bigger screens) - #22 by keunes
- The proposed implementation was mocked up in line with Material Design v3 here: Bottom navigation · Issue #4376 · AntennaPod/AntennaPod · GitHub
- The implementation seems to have been merged as https://github.com/AntennaPod/AntennaPod/commit/6cbc58ba78caf311a706823a8784ef4453743024 in September 2024
One thing does puzzle me though—Material Design v3 says that the navigation bar (aka “Bottom Navigation”) should be used when there are 3-5 destinations. On the other hand, a navigation drawer (current “side navigation”) seems to be recommended for 5 or more destinations, which AntennaPod does have. We have Home, Queue, Episodes, Subscriptions, Inbox, Downloads, Playback history, Favorites, Statistics—all of which leads to the “More” screen and also a selection.
Just based on this alone, shouldn’t the app be going with purely a navigation drawer (side navigation) rather than shoehorning our large number of destinations into a navigation bar (bottom navigation) that has a “More” section?